Social Media In Divorce Proceedings: Computers And Email
Email is another minefield or goldmine, depending on whose emails are being used in the case. If one party has legal access to the other partys email account, the transmissions sent by the address owner will be evidence admissible in Court. There are objections to emails received by the owner , however, they can be managed by subpoenas to the internet service providers for their records to demonstrate who owns the accounts from which the emails were sent. The information contained in the email is a constant source of information in a case: helpful or harmful to your client. He or she can best protect himself by not using a home computer for any confidential transmissions or ones about which he/she may be vulnerable. Likewise, work computer records are susceptible to subpoena for those transmissions that are sent/received that are not work-related.
To prepare a subpoena for a specific email account, you need to have the accounts holders personal details. If you do not have them, you can sometimes look through fee-based online email tracing services. You can issue a subpoena directly to the email accounts service provider who will be obligated to provide all required information about the account. Be prepared to have a Court review the responses to email requests for relevancy.
Social Media Content Can be Used as Evidence
How do you get it? Several courts have held that social media is discoverable for three main reasons:
Digital Evidence Is A Double
If you can gather information from emails, text messages, and social media posts, your spouse can do the same. Often, parties to a divorce will cull the information that supports their case and leave contextual references out. This can make someone appear very undeserving of support, assets, and even child custody. For this reason, you may want to keep records of your own communications to counter the meaning of any evidence admitted against you. Context matters in digital communications.
An experienced Sacramento family law attorney can help you with digital evidence including emails and text messages in many ways. Your legal representative will help you acquire digital information you can use in court to support your case, protect you from unfair information your spouse may use against you, and help you mitigate the risk of your digital presence during and after your divorce.
With an understanding of how people use digital communications in divorce proceedings, everyone should consider the consequences of their digital communications. What you say today in jest or seriousness could come back to haunt you tomorrow. To protect yourself in an increasingly digital world, never post anything on a public or private message forum that you wouldnt feel comfortable with others seeing. Even joking about taking your spouse to the cleaners in a social media post could hurt divorce proceedings.
Can My Husband Or Wife See My Text Messages
A million questions swirl in the mind of the soon to be divorced. What will happen to my kids? What will happen to my retirement money? And, perhaps more immediately, can my husband or wife see my text messages?
What Are Text Messages?
At the time of this writing, 2019, everyone communicates via text message. Text messages are electronic messages transmitted over SMS or Internet connection. Text messages are almost always transmitted via smartphone. Text messages stay on your phone until you delete themor do they?
Text messages are like any other form of electronic communication. They are a series of zeros and ones that are recorded somewhere. If you turn off your phone and restart it, the messages come back. Are they saved? Are they reloaded from a server somewhere?
How are Text Messages Used In Court?
No matter where text messages are saved they are a common piece of evidence in divorce and parentage cases. Text messages are entered into evidence during a court proceeding to prove something was said by one party to another. Because theres almost always a back and forth with text messages, the court can examine both the message and the context the message was sent within. Text messages for the most part are presented to the court as screenshots.
But, a period of time of text messages from one person to another can be provided by the cell phone service provider after serving a subpoena to the cell phone service provider who will then provide months of text messages
Don’t Miss: Fl Parenting Class For Divorce
What Documents Do I Have To Provide To Obtain A Foreign Divorce Opinion Letter
The lawyer will need the following information to complete the necessary research, and draft the foreign divorce opinion letter, so please bring these documents to your appointment:
- Completed Application for Marriage Completed by each of the parties that intend to marry.
- The Divorce Decree The original, or a copy that is certified by the court.
- Statement of Sole Responsibility Both of the parties that intend to marry must sign it.
- Signed Statement Confirming Residency in Divorce Jurisdiction Written by the individual that is divorced to confirm that they or their previous spouse resided in the jurisdiction where the divorce was granted for a minimum of 1 year before submitting the application for divorce .
NOTE: Mail Service is Available.
If you are unable to visit our office in person for an appointment, we offer a convenient mail-in service, which includes having our firm review and submit the Foreign Divorce Opinion Letter on your behalf to the Marriage Office, as well as completing the letter. The fee for the mail service is $125 + HST, which is added to the fee for the foreign divorce opinion letter.
Get A Free Consultation
Can A Divorce Attorney Subpoena Text Messages
Can a divorce attorney subpoena text messages?
Subpoena for text messages is a difficult area of discovery practice. The fact is that the service provider, absent some bizarre situation, does not store the information, so obtaining text messages really must come from the opposing party. We have been successful in obtaining text messages through subpoenas, but success in that area is not common.
There is no simple answer to this question, unfortunately.
Content of text messages can reveal any manner of transgressions. During a contested divorce, one party may request to subpoena the other partys text messages to prove unfaithfulness, dishonesty about finances, potential danger to shared children, or many other grounds for divorce.
Subpoenaing text messages isnt usually an option because most service providers do not store the actual messages, only a record of phone numbers that sent and received messages. Therefore, we can easily establish communication between two people, but in some instances, even that information may not be available from the provider. And just because there is a communication thread, that doesnt necessarily prove misconduct.
We have been successful in obtaining messages through subpoenas in some divorce proceedings, but it is not common to have success in this area because the text must be authenticated. To authenticate a text, one of three things must happen:
1) The accused party admits sending the text
3) We must prove response authentication
Don’t Miss: St Louis Mo Divorce Law
What Are The Disadvantages Of Pleading The Fifth
Furthermore, as a defendant in a criminal trial, if you choose to exercise your rights under the 5th Amendment, you may not testify at all during the trial. While that might reduce the risk that incriminating evidence will come to light, it will also preclude you from presenting any testimony that could exonerate you.
Using Phone Records To Prove Adultery
When a spouse suspects adultery, the information in any of their shared phone records can be used against the other. Even if the suspected spouse elects not to provide those records, your attorney can petition the court to get them from your carrier.
But when providers retain records, these typically only indicate the identities of the involved parties and the date and time of the call or text, but not the exact content of the messages. The device itself can often provide more exact records of the content of the communications. Consequently, it is important for a spouse who suspects adultery to preserve message content on their own as much as possible.
Recommended Reading: How To Go About Divorce Proceedings
Can Cell Phone Records Be Used In Court During A Divorce
Most people are attached to their smartphones, which can include their email, records of calls, text messages, photos, and more. While you might believe that you have privacy when using your cell phone, these records are increasingly being used as evidence in divorce cases.
If you have a no-fault divorce and you and your spouse agree on the relevant issues in your case, there would be no need for phone records to come into play. However, in some cases, these records can be important evidence to prove your claims or defend against your spouses claims.
Can Investigators Trace Deleted Whatsapp Messages
We do not retain data for law enforcement purposes unless we receive a valid preservation request before a user has deleted that content from our service. In the ordinary course of providing our service, WhatsApp does not store messages once they are delivered or transaction logs of such delivered messages.
Read Also: States With Highest Divorce Rates
When Are Phone Records Relevant To A Divorce
Phone records may be subpoenaed whenever the contents of those records are helpful in resolving an issue at stake in the divorce proceeding. There are a number of issues common to divorce proceedings that might benefit from private phone records. For example, during a custody dispute, one party might point to the others extramarital affair or current dating and living situation as evidence that that party should have lesser custody rights. Phone calls and text messages with the paramour might provide evidence to support that point, such as by showing that the romantic interest stays at the home with the children regularly.
Phone records might also be used to unearth hidden accounts and other assets. Wealthy parties often try to hide assets from a divorce in order to retain more of their wealth. Texts, emails, phone calls, calendar appointments, and other phone records could be used to track down these hidden assets and prove that one spouse was knowingly hiding them. Phone records might also be used to show extravagant spending to prove one spouse was wasting marital assets and should be entitled to a smaller share of the marital estate.
Can You Subpoena Snapchat Records For A Divorce
Yes. You or your lawyer can subpoena records from social media platforms like Snapchat, Facebook, Instagram, etc. In some cases, you can just ask your spouse to supply their messaging or posting history. However, if they refuse, you can still subpoena the information.
Many divorce lawyers dont need to subpoena social media communications. Thats because most posts are available publicly. While it may be challenging to obtain messages from Snapchat and similar platforms, its certainly possible.
If your social media records are being subpoenaed, its in your best interest to comply. Erasing your account after the subpoena is issued may lead to penalties.
Also Check: Questions To Ask About Divorce
Can A Lawyer Subpoena Text Messages That Have Been Deleted
As mentioned above, a divorce lawyer cant subpoena the actual content of a text message. However, if a spouse deletes a text from their phone, that communication record can still be subpoenaed. If the telecom company deletes the records, they cannot be retrieved.
For this reason, its essential to request a subpoena as early as possible. Otherwise, the information may be lost forever.
Social Media In Divorce Proceedings: Cell Phones
Text messaging is the most common form of divorce evidence. More than 90% of Americas top divorce attorneys said they have seen a spike in the number of cases using evidence from text communications in the past three years, according to the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers .
Texts are the source of great embarrassment if one spouse keeps texts sent during times of anger or frustration, or when socially involved and not being mindful of their words. Likewise, texts sent to children or to friends and family members can show a mental state or disposition that contradicts the carefully constructed disposition that has been crafted to appear calm and neutral. Texts tend to be reflexive, people do not think about them, they exist in a context of immediacy and spontaneity. They provide a window that provides perhaps a reflection of someones real thoughts and intentions at times when they are not thinking like a litigant.
Texts can be printed. Clients can send you the entire chain of texts between spouses so attorneys can review them in toto to see if there is any gold in that mountain. We as advocates need to tell our clients that if they do not want a judge to see it, dont write it down.
The new applications for cell phones grow daily. This writer does not claim to be knowledgeable about those new and perhaps useful ones. Good management may be leaving your cell phone wherever there can be no embarrassing information revealed by its presence.
Read Also: How To Get Divorce In Illinois
Can My Phone Records Be Subpoenaed Without My Knowledge
No, subpoenaed phone records in divorce cases require the spouse whose phone records are being subpoenaed to be notified. There is no other way to do it. Federal laws prohibit telecom service providers from providing certain kinds of information. For instance, they can provide records concerning the communication but not the actual content within the communications.
You dont have to agree with the subpoena for it to go forward. If one spouse believes the other is hiding relevant information, their divorce lawyer can easily request your records.
Once the records have been subpoenaed, a judge will decide if the information is relevant to the divorce case. If it is, then the evidence will be admissible. If it is not, the court will not use the information to determine the cases outcome.
What Is A Subpoena
A subpoena is a legal request to one party requiring they produce information relevant to the proceedings. Subpoena is a Latin term that means under penalty. That means that any person receiving a subpoena must comply with its terms. If they do not, they risk both civil and criminal penalties.
Generally, there are three kinds of subpoenas in divorce cases. They include:
Its important to note that divorce subpoena laws vary slightly from state to state. If you are unsure of your states divorce subpoena guidelines, it will help to contact an experienced family law lawyer to discuss your case in detail.
Read Also: Divorce Lawyers In Florence South Carolina
The Problems With Getting Text Messages
The problem with requesting and obtaining text messages is often more practical than legal. People often struggle to find a way to format and print text messages in a way that makes them user friendly as evidence in court. When printed, chains of text messages are often disjointed with one-half of one message being on the bottom of one page, and then the whole message appearing again at the top of the next page. It can be difficult to follow a text conversation once printed. In addition, when printed, it can often times be difficult to easily identify the date and time a message was sent. There are programs you can use to more readily print the text messages into a user-friendly format, but they produce mixed results and they dont work across all formats and all types of cellphones.
As indicated, if you want text message evidence from the other party, the easiest thing to do is to request it from them and then ask the court to order them to produce it if they refuse. If they have deleted the messages, this produces a whole another set of potentially expensive problems.
The Impact Of Email And Text Message Evidence In Divorce Proceedings
Divorce proceedings have significantly changed with the advent of digital technology. Today, attorneys frequently acquire digital records and successfully admit them into evidence. The way the courts treat digital evidence today is shaping the judicial system of the future. California courts often admit email and text messages into evidence, which can significantly change the outcome of a divorce matter.
Recommended Reading: Divorce Lawyers In St Petersburg Fl
What Is Considered Adultery In A Divorce
Adultery is commonly defined as: The voluntary sexual intercourse by a married person with someone other than the offenders spouse. It is important to understand that Adultery is a crime in many jurisdictions, although it is rarely prosecuted. State law typically defines Adultery as vaginal intercourse, only.
So How Do You Get Text Messages By Subpoena
1. First, it is best to try and get the cell phone company to retain the content of the text messages by sending a letter to the carrier explaining that the text messages are evidence and must be preserved. It is wise to have an attorney draft and send the letter, citing the relevant provisions of the Stored Communications Act and applicable state law. The letter should be sent certified by overnight delivery.
2. Second, prepare the subpoena to seek the relevant text message.
3. Third, file an ex parte motion with your divorce court and request that court order the other party to sign a notarized consent to release the text messages.
4. Fourth, serve the subpoena. This may be tricky depending on what state your divorce is being handled, as the rules for service vary from state to state. You may need to have a commission set up in the state that the cell carriers records are kept to ensure the subpoena is properly served.
Obviously, this is a significant amount of work. Fortunately, there are far better options.
Recommended Reading: Free Divorce Papers In Arkansas
Can Divorce Lawyer Subpoena Bank Records
If bank accounts are only in your spouse’s name, or if he or she has separate business bank accounts, your lawyer may request a subpoena for bank records. You have other options for obtaining financial information besides waiting for your spouse to turn it in.
If bank accounts are only in your spouse’s name, or if he or she has separate business bank accounts, your lawyer may request a subpoena for bank records. You have other options for obtaining financial information besides waiting for your spouse to turn it in. In a divorce, either spouse can directly send a subpoena to third parties with financial information relevant to the case. A duces tecum subpoena requires the third party recipient to serve the documents.
Attorneys routinely send these subpoenas to banks, credit card companies, retirement account managers, and other financial account holders. Subpoenas can be enforced by going to court. You can file a motion with the court to compel your spouse to provide the requested material. The judge will review the summons and, if you meet the legal requirements, will issue an order for your spouse to serve the papers.
Your divorce lawyer will hire an investigator who can follow the trail of money, your spouse’s habit while traveling and on vacation, and will use similar means to find out hidden assets. If you have additional questions about obtaining financial information from a spouse during your divorce, you should contact a local family law attorney for advice. . .